SetTV ordered to pay $90 million to Dish

Discussions about the latest legal news in the TV industry.
Post Reply
rusty
TVRO Guru
TVRO Guru
Articles: 0
Posts: 374
Joined: Sat Jul 26, 2014 6:52 pm

SetTV ordered to pay $90 million to Dish

Post by rusty » Wed Nov 14, 2018 1:53 am

SETTV :hammerhead IPTV Service Ordered to Pay DISH $90,000,000 in Piracy Damages
BY ANDY ON NOVEMBER 13, 2018

SETTV, an under-fire IPTV service previously sued by several Hollywood studios, has suffered a crushing blow in another US-based lawsuit. After being sued by DISH Network and Nagrastar for retransmitting the former's content without authorization, SETTV has now agreed to pay the plaintiffs more than $90 million while shutting down and handing over its domains and equipment.

Back in April, the Alliance for Creativity and Entertainment, the global anti-piracy alliance featuring several Hollywood studios, Amazon, Netflix, and dozens of other entertainment companies, sued Florida-based SET Broadcast, LLC.

The popular unauthorized IPTV was accused of being a piracy tool offering copyright-infringing streams to a large number of subscribers. Early June, SETTV went offline after a second lawsuit was filed against the company.

In a Florida court, DISH Network and encryption partner NagraStar sued several individuals, companies and trusts collectively doing business as SETTV via the domain SETTVNOW.com. The plaintiffs stated that the complex business structure was designed to frustrate enforcement efforts and hide profits made by SET Broadcast and various individuals.

“Defendants created a pirate streaming television service they have branded ‘SET TV’,” the complaint reads, citing offenses under the Federal Communications Act (FCA).

“Defendants sell subscriptions and devices for the SET TV pirate streaming service, which includes numerous television channels that were received without authorization from DISH’s satellite service and were subsequently retransmitted without authorization on the SET TV pirate streaming service.”

DISH and NagraStar alleged that “for only $20 per month”, SET TV gave users access to more than 500 live channels, including on-demand content and PPV broadcasts. The company also sold pre-configured hardware devices that came pre-loaded with the SET TV application. As a result, the plaintiffs demanded a permanent injunction plus huge damages.

In an agreed judgment handed down by a Florida court (the merits of the case were not considered), the demands of DISH and NagraStar have now been met.

“DISH is awarded statutory damages of $90,199,000 under the FCA. The statutory damages are calculated at the parties’ agreed upon $500 for each of the 180,398 subscribers that were acquired directly by Defendants and provided with unauthorized access to DISH’s television programming using Defendants’ SetTV streaming service. Defendants are jointly and severally liable for all damages awarded herein,” the judgment reads.

The defendants in the case (and anyone acting in concert with them) are also permanently enjoined from “receiving, retransmitting, or copying, or assisting others in receiving, retransmitting, or copying, any of DISH’s satellite or over-the-top Internet transmissions of television programming or any content contained therein without authorization”, and having any dealings with infringing subscriptions, set-top devices, or applications.

DISH also won the right to take ownership of all SETTV-branded set-top boxes, similar devices sold through resellers and affiliates, plus subscription codes, passwords and applications relating to the SETTV service.

Additionally, SETTV is required to hand over any domains relating to its service, including but not limited to SETTVNOW.com and SETBROADCAST.com.

“The judgment and injunction against the SetTV service marks a significant victory in the ongoing fight against pay-TV piracy, and a win for consumers who subscribe to legitimate pay-TV services,” DISH said in a statement.

“Following extensive discovery, DISH and the SetTV Defendants reached a confidential settlement agreement. Pursuant to that agreement, the Parties filed stipulated facts and admissions of liability by the SetTV Defendants, along with an agreed judgment and permanent injunction that was entered by the Court on October 24, 2018.

“In compliance with the Court’s injunction, the SetTV service has been shut down permanently and the websites used to operate the service, along with all remaining inventory of receivers and subscription codes, will be forfeited for destruction.”

In common with similarly large damages rulings, it’s unlikely that SETTV will pay anything like the amount cited by the Court. However, the $90m judgment makes great headlines and is likely to act as a deterrent to all but the most aggressive US-based pirates.

The original complaint and subsequent judgment can be found here and here (pdf) :judge:


https://torrentfreak.com/settv-iptv-ser ... es-181113/
12' Cosmos Primestar (refurbished)36" SuperJack Actuator
Chaparral Corotor Feed (Norsat 8115, 4106A)
ZGemmaH7 UHD, OctagonSX88 HD, Edision UHD, DSR-6000, DSR-6050
Clarke Belt: 22W - 133W

User avatar
Claude Greiner
TVRO Member
TVRO Member
Articles: 0
Posts: 5
Joined: Thu Jun 01, 2017 12:16 am

Re: SetTV ordered to pay $90 million to Dish

Post by Claude Greiner » Fri Nov 16, 2018 12:19 am

Just the tip of the iceberg if you ask me. Dish Network's piracy problem is out of control and Nagra is completely clueless. :kook :retarded IPTV pirates are selling Dish programming all around the world. I've seen ads offering America's Top 250 for as low as $1.50 per month. Things are so bad I haven't installed a new directv sub in months. My phone in the office hardly rings anymore that I've forgotten what it sounds like. :utterlyconfused
Claude Greiner

In Memory of Tiger Stadium
April 28th 1896 - September 21st 2009

Blackloz
TVRO Member
TVRO Member
Articles: 0
Posts: 21
Joined: Sat Jan 06, 2018 10:24 pm

Re: SetTV ordered to pay $90 million to Dish

Post by Blackloz » Fri Nov 16, 2018 10:29 pm

Dish network programming is also being streamed overseas by BTV:

https://www.multichannel.com/news/progr ... ervice-btv

xray
New Member
New Member
Articles: 0
Posts: 1
Joined: Fri Nov 16, 2018 9:56 pm

Re: SetTV ordered to pay $90 million to Dish

Post by xray » Sat Nov 17, 2018 9:36 pm

Hmmm, let's see why dish is never likely to secure their signal again. A single lawsuit nets them a customer list with 180,398 names on it.

180,398 x $3500 = $631 million

How many subs would they need to generate the same amount of profit? Let's assume $100 of profit per sub per year. That works out to 6.3 million subs. At the moment, they are losing over a million subs per year. Adding 6.3 million new subs seems like a pipe dream.

Dish is now in the extortion business, programmers be damned! :reddevil:

Any questions?

User avatar
fatso
TVRO Guru
TVRO Guru
Articles: 0
Posts: 877
Joined: Wed Aug 13, 2014 7:46 pm
Been thanked: 4 times

Re: SetTV ordered to pay $90 million to Dish

Post by fatso » Mon Nov 19, 2018 1:07 am

DOJ already cracked down on dish and told them to stop going after end users. They can only prosecute commercial outfits like settv. Charlie needs to get his house in order. This settv thing was pie in the face for him :oops: and made headlines everywhere.
12ft Mesh Dish
C-Band Enthusiast since 1983

Post Reply

Return to “Legal News”